
A cap-rate comparison between short-term and long-term rental strategy — using real portfolio numbers, not brochure math.
Every investor asks the same question eventually: long-term rental for stability, or short-term rental for yield? In most of Central Ohio, that’s a real debate. In Hocking Hills, it isn’t close.
The demand side
Hocking Hills has been a tourism story for years — Forbes-list recognition, steady visitor growth, and a hiking, waterfall, and cabin-culture draw that a traditional long-term rental simply cannot monetize. I bought a five-bedroom house on five wooded acres that rented to a single family for $2,200 a month, and turned it into a short term rental generating $10,000 per month.
The regulatory side — still favorable, for now
Hocking County remains one of Ohio’s more investor-accessible STR markets at the county level, with basic registration and tax collection as the current bar rather than caps or zoning restrictions. That is a meaningfully lighter lift than what operators face in tightly regulated resort towns or urban cores elsewhere in the state.
The trade-offs, honestly
- STR revenue is seasonal and weather-sensitive; long-term rental income is flat and predictable
- STR requires active operations — turnover, guest communication, maintenance cadence — or a management layer to handle it
- STR carries higher per-unit furnishing and setup cost than a standard rental
- Regulatory change is actively in motion at the county level (more on that below) — today’s light-touch environment is not guaranteed to stay light-touch
Cash flow is a spreadsheet. Cap rate is a spreadsheet with better inputs. Hocking Hills, run correctly, changes the inputs in your favor.
The verdict
For the right property — space, privacy, proximity to the trail system — short-term operation in Hocking Hills outperforms long-term rental on both cash flow and appreciation potential, because the buyer pool for a well-run STR asset includes both future operators and second-home buyers, not just landlords. That’s a bigger exit market, not just a bigger monthly check.
Want the real numbers behind a Hocking Hills STR conversion? Let’s run your specific property against both models.
Go here to schedule a no-cost, no-commitment consultation with Kyle.
About the Author
Kyle Alfriend is a top-producing real estate expert in Central Ohio with over 40 years of experience, helping over 3,000 clients buy, sell, and invest in real estate. Nationally recognized for his prospecting and negotiation strategies, he has been featured on CNN, FOX News, Fortune, and Forbes. Beyond real estate, Kyle is deeply committed to making an impact in the community through charitable initiatives and fundraising efforts.
Kyle Alfriend
The Alfriend Group / ReMax Achievers
(614) 395-1776
Kyle@AlfriendGroup.com
www.AlfriendGroup.com